Best Pizza Winner:

2003 – 2021

Best Pizza Winner:


“This landmark pizza joint has been slinging unbeatable, super thin-crust pies in a family-friendly, dive-bar atmosphere for almost 70 years. Walk in and you may see a kids’ birthday party taking place right next to some old geezers watching the game. If you grew up going to Star Tavern, it’s definitely because your parents- and maybe even your grandparents- did, too.”

Rose Maura Lorre


"Star Tavern is a go-to pizzeria for thin-crust bar-style pies... 'This place serves the best bar pies I've had. They're super thin and super cheap and always satisfying.'"
"No one does true thin-crust pizza like Jersey... And no one does thin-crust better than Star... Don't be fooled by the sports-bar atmosphere. This is a Jersey pizza shrine."
"New York has nothing on the thin-crust pizzas served at this classic Jersey 70's bar & pizzeria."​
Play Video

Online Articles:

Star Tavern World Famous Pizzeria logo

Get in Touch


Pints & Pies for a Purpose

1 in 12 households in the country are experiencing food insecurity. You can help. CLICK HERE  to purchase tickets to a Star pizza & beer pairing at Four City Brewing. Can’t make it? You can still donate on the website!

*2002, Food Research & Action Center