400 High Street, Orange, NJ 07050
(973) 675-3336

What more can we say...

Ranked 2nd best pizzeria in America. - The Daily Meal 2015
"New York has nothing on the thin-crust pizzas served at this classic Jersey 70's bar and pizzeria." - 2016
"Star is the gold standard for thin-crust in New Jersey" - Genovese 2015
"Best Pizza" - NJ Monthly Readers Poll, North Jersey 2003-2012
WINNER, Star Ledger Pizza Patrol - Best Thin Crust Pizza in NJ, 2010
"Best Pizza Winner" - AOL City Guide, Northern New Jersey, 2007
"Delectable" - New Jersey Monthly, Cheap Eats, February 2007
"Best Pie in North Jersey" - New Jersey Life Magazine, October 2006
"Best in State" - New Jersey Countryside Magazine, July/August 2005
"Top Dog Honors" - Star Ledger Munchmobile, 2003
"Absolutely Scrumptious!" - West Orange High School Paper, 2003
"Best Overall Pzza" - Glen Ridge High School Paper, 2003
"New Jersey's Favorite Bar Pie" - Star Ledger Munchmobile, 1999
"Very good" - New York Times, May 14, 1995
"Renowned for Superior Light Crusted Pizza" - New York Times, 1992

Click the covers to see articles about the Star Tavern

(links will open in a new window)





Stay connected with us

400 High Street
Orange, NJ 07050
(973) 675-3336

Hours of Operation:

  Monday - Saturday: 11am - 10pm
  Sunday: 12pm - 9pm